Homemade Hard Ice Cream

All of our hard ice cream flavors are homemade on site, made without artificial flavors or colors, and are available exclusively at Bailiwick Market & Cafe!


SHOW ME THE DOUGH - COOKIE DOUGH ICE CREAM IS FINALLY HERE! Our creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with chunks of homemade cookie dough.

NEED S'MORE COWBELL - chocolate ice cream with a homemade marshmallow swirl and bits of homemade graham cracker crumbs (named after the famous SNL skit... check it out here!).

JUST GOT DUMPED - chocolate ice cream with chocolate cookie crumbs, chocolate covered potato chips, chocolate covered pretzel bits, and toffee bits coated in our homemade homemade caramel.

MUDDY MINT - mint ice cream with chunks of homemade brownie.

Field of Creams Homemade Flavors:

VANILLA - creamy with a hint of butterscotch.

6A60CA76 8CCC 4E8B B4B7 E39668F6373E

FILTHY RICH CHOCOLATE - creamy, rich chocolate with a subtle coffee finish.

1D667323 C686 4F88 AC17 509691352005

FARM GIRL SWIRL - a robust coffee ice cream base with a homemade dark fudge swirl.

844EA706 31E7 4625 9B77 2A9682B95F36

MAPLE WALNUT - pure NY maple syrup ice cream with toasted walnuts.

E4C07EFF 3C47 4D9A AF8E DAB687B705F4

MAPLE PECAN - pure NY maple syrup ice cream with pecan pralines.

781AA1FE 9C28 4A31 8124 05D57C0D2A5A

MOLASSES CRINKLE - molasses ice cream with chunks of homemade molasses crinkle cookies, made from a generations old recipe.

D14ABB58 BC2F 45B3 9644 F749FCAE23D6

LAKE EFFECT - toasted coconut ice cream, toasted almonds, and a homemade dark fudge swirl.

7E5D0EC8 F24F 4D52 881E 11357B6F68D2

DIRT ROAD - rich chocolate ice cream, homemade chocolate cookie crumbs, and a crunchy peanut butter swirl.

B87FDE31 D161 4E97 8B31 95CF85CF0411

FUDGE SMUDGE - creamy vanilla ice cream with a homemade dark chocolate fudge swirl.

F1AFEB5A B198 4D88 8160 2B02987E4E16

TOASTED ALMOND BUTTERSCOTCH - butterscotch ice cream, homemade butterscotch swirl, and toasted almonds.

533AE965 00D8 4E2E AD7B 19096A30B64B

PEPPERMINT FUDGE - creamy peppermint ice cream with a homemade dark fudge swirl.

MINT CHOCOLATE CHIP - creamy peppermint ice cream with dark mint chocolate chips.

FB398624 1AB2 402D B796 E1B736A06AFC

PRALINES AND CREAM - caramel ice cream with a caramel swirl and chunks of pecan pralines.

49D19351 5E69 45C5 AE9D 2B42670520C3

SPOTTED COW - creamy vanilla ice cream with chunks of 60% cocoa chocolate chips.

E06FF738 B121 47EA 8D10 83F4AFC84255

PB&J - creamy peanut butter ice cream, a crunchy peanut butter swirl, and a homemade jelly swirl.

LEMON BAR - vanilla ice cream with homemade shortbread cookies and a homemade lemon swirl.

COFFEE N TOFFEE - robust coffee ice cream with bits of homemade toffee and a dark fudge swirl.

B3EBD09D 2CCD 4CE6 8303 B8E65D7D7927

COFFEE CHIP - robust coffee ice cream with 60% cocoa chocolate chips.

60E9BA2B E4A6 4878 B256 F5FD78048273

MILK AND COOKIES - vanilla ice cream with chunks of homemade chocolate wafer cookies and buttercream (our version of the popular Cookies 'n Cream).

0DCDFB2E D606 49C3 8152 D6A751EF22E1

PEANUT BUTTER BLOSSOM - vanilla ice cream with a homemade crunchy peanut butter swirl and homemade fudge swirl.

POT O' GOLD - butterscotch ice cream with a butterscotch swirl and chocolate butterscotch chips.

51A808FA 6CD7 44EB 9B67 722007C74FFB

BLACK RASPBERRY (seasonal) - creamy black raspberry ice cream made with berries grown on our own hillside!

RAD RASPBERRY CHIP (seasonal) - ice cream made with local red raspberries and finished with dark and white raspberry-flavored chocolate chips.

658C923D AAC6 40A5 9417 7CCCE2519772

IMG 1649

Contact Us

Bailiwick Market & Café
441 Route 5
Elbridge, NY 13060
(315) 277-5632

Cafe and Ice Cream Hours - kitchen closes at 8:00 pm
Everyday: 8:00am to 9:00pm

Drive Thru
Everyday: 8:00am to 8:00pm


Ice Cream Open:
Everyday: 8:00am - 9:00pm

Subscribe to our mailing list